Crumbl Cookie Review
Written by: Reed Dulany, Britt McCormick, Edward Wallace, and Liam Murphy
Strawberry Biscoff Cookie:= The Strawberry Biscoff cookie from Crumbl has a soft, buttery base topped with sweet strawberry flavor and rich Biscoff spread that adds a caramel-like taste. The combination of fruity and cookie-butter flavors makes it unique and very indulgent. It’s sweet but balanced by the slight spice from the Biscoff. Overall, it’s a fun and flavorful cookie that stands out from more traditional options.
We rate it an 8 out of 10.
Galaxy Brownie Cookie: The Galaxy Brownie cookie tastes like a rich chocolate brownie in cookie form. It’s dense, fudgy, and packed with deep chocolate flavor, making it perfect for chocolate lovers. The texture is soft and slightly gooey, similar to an underbaked brownie. Overall, it’s very rich and satisfying, especially if you want something extra chocolatey.
We rate it a 7 out of 10.
Cinnamon Square: The Cinnamon Square is a soft, thick cookie with a warm cinnamon flavor. It tastes sweet and a little buttery, kind of like a snickerdoodle. The edges are slightly crispy, but the middle stays soft and chewy. The sugar on top gives it a tiny crunch. It smells really good and feels cozy, especially with milk or a warm drink.
We rate it a solid 8 out of 10.
Sea Salt Toffee Cookie: The Sea Salt Toffee Cookie is sweet with a little bit of salt on top. It has crunchy toffee pieces mixed into the soft cookie dough. When you bite it, you get a chewy center and slightly crispy edges. The salt makes the sweet flavor stand out more. It’s rich, buttery, and really satisfying to eat.
We rate it a 7 out of 10.
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip: The Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip cookie from Crumbl is a great twist on a classic chocolate chip cookie. It’s thick, soft, and gooey in the middle with rich semi-sweet chocolate chunks that keep it from being too sugary. The light sprinkle of salt balances the sweetness and makes the flavor stand out more. Overall, it tastes like an upgraded homemade cookie and is one of the best simple options on the menu.
We rate it a solid 8 out of 10.
Snickerdoodle Cookie: The Snickerdoodle cookie from Crumbl is soft, warm, and coated in a sweet cinnamon-sugar topping that gives it a classic homemade flavor. The texture is fluffy and slightly chewy, making it really comforting and easy to enjoy. It isn’t overly sweet, so the cinnamon flavor stands out nicely. Overall, it’s a simple but good cookie that’s perfect if you like traditional flavors.
We rate this a solid 6 out of 10.
